Wednesday, March 25, 2015

Workshops Work if You Put in the Work

You can lead a horse to water but you can’t make him drink. Replace “horse” with “student”, “water” with “a textbook”, and “drink” with “read”, and you’ve got a pretty accurate sentiment. I mean, no one really expects high school students to read textbooks that are eight or nine hundred pages long, do they? Well, the sad reality is, yes, some people do. After all, textbooks tell kids everything they need to know, right? And what’s more, many are aligned to those wonderful state and national standards that seem to be the end all be all in education nowadays.
Alright, let’s take a break from the sarcasm for a second. Plain and simple, textbooks are not the paragon of academic reading that they are made out to be. Sure, they contain vast amounts of information in one place and are therefore not completely invaluable. However, the information within textbooks is often so condensed and cherry-picked (and sometimes inaccurate) that we can’t seriously expect any real learning to be enacted solely by a cover-to-cover reading. No, instead we must use textbooks sparingly and supplement them with other reading materials that are fresher, more accessible, and less sterile. 
So how do we make sure that our students are getting something out of the textbooks when we actually do use them? Well, we have to make sure that they are equipped with varied and effective reading strategies. As educators, we must model and actively teach good reading habits and strategies so that our students can get the most out of what they are reading and take in the information on a deeper and more impactful level. Preparing students to read with pre-reading activities, encouraging them to ask questions, take notes, and make connections while they are reading, and answering questions, drawing conclusions, and summarizing what they’ve read after the fact will allow students to be active readers not just passive sponges that absorb (or more often, don’t) what they read in thick, heavy textbooks.
What about reading materials that aren’t textbooks? Well for those, we have reading workshops. Now that’s not to say that reading workshops cannot be used for textbooks, but they are more effective and more appropriate for materials such as articles or novels. Reading workshops allow students to delve into more exciting and more accessible content area material that is connected to and has meaning in the real world. Students can network with one another and discuss what they have read accurately and effectively if they have some accountability for their reading material. Reading workshops are also an invaluable tool for classroom management, as they allow teachers to speak with students one-on-one to check progress and understanding, as well as provide support. The physical movement of the teacher also encourages students to be on task gives teachers a better handle on the atmosphere of the classroom.

My only real concern with what I read in these two chapters of Daniels and Zemelman is the sheer number of reading strategies provided. I’m not saying that the variety and number itself is problematic, rather knowing how, when, and to what degree to implement them is. The authors provide us with twenty-six strategies that we can teach and model for our students. That’s quite a few, and I’m sure there are dozens of others they did not discuss, as well as combinations and variations of the ones they did. So how do we know which ones to teach? We can’t realistically teach them all. So do we pick our favorites and try and push those? Do we keep teaching and modeling until we find two or three that work? I found the reading strategies chapter overwhelming as a teacher candidate, so I can only imagine how students would feel if they had this multitude of strategies and ideas thrown at them. I would think that like any teaching tool, it must be used sparingly and only when truly effective. If it doesn’t work, don’t force it. Just go with the flow and adjust as necessary. But this is generally easier said than done. It’s something I’ll have to explore once when I get into a classroom. How can I strike a balance between using good strategies and letting ones that are not practical for my own particular situation go?  





Wednesday, March 18, 2015

Textbooks! What Are They Good For? Absolutely… Something (D&Z 6+7)

“Don’t assign the whole textbook.” That’s one of the first headings in chapter six of Daniels and Zemelman’s Subjects Matter, and what a novel idea it is. That’s not sarcasm, either. A lot of teachers and administrators could stand to hear that. We are so often concerned with just covering all the material that we fail to realize that making students read an entire book is a nearly impossible and Herculean task. Not every aspect of a content area deserves the same attention and so as educators, we are faced with the difficult and unfortunate task of having to decide what is important and deserves our time and consideration and what is not and should be skipped. Ideally, we would be able to cover all aspects of every subject we teach, but this is just not practical and is not an effective way to teach, especially in regards to the use of textbooks.
The two ideas discussed in this reading that I really liked were jigsawing and the Guide-o-Rama. This was not the first time I had heard of jigsawing, but I think this was the first time that I really saw just how effective it could potentially be, if used correctly. Jigsawing allows you to reduce the workload (i.e., ridiculous amounts of reading) that students have to do and also facilitates group discussion, which can be immensely useful in getting students to open up, think critically, and communicate their ideas with one another. I thought the Guide-o-Rama was great (despite the cheesy name) for a very different reason. In those situations where your students will have to slog through a chapter or two of the book with no reprieve, the Guide-o-Rama can really help them know what they should be focusing on and to what degree. So often, textbooks these days are filled with so many asides in the form of secondary text boxes, graphs, maps, charts, and anecdotes that it can be difficult to know what to read, what to skip, and what’s actually important. Providing students with a guide that tells them what to read, with what depth, and perhaps in what order will undoubtedly make things easier for them. In addition, the ability to add in your own thoughts and tips will allow the students to know your feelings about the text and know that you had some difficulties or questions with it yourself. This is all a part of making yourself more accessible to the students.
The chapter on building a community of learners was, to me, the less interesting of the two. That’s not to say that it doesn’t contain some important information, though. Establishing your classroom as a safe place for asking questions, an environment of accountability, and a community where people of all different backgrounds work towards a common goal is pivotal in being an effective educator. You need to build students’ trust and bolster their self-esteem so that they will feel accepted socially, which helps them infinitely academically. I had a professor a couple of semesters ago who constantly stressed that asking questions is important, that there is no such a thing as a stupid question, and that we should not hesitate to ask questions if we had them. That really struck me, because a lot of teachers may relate that sentiment halfheartedly, but this professor really seemed to mean it. I think that creating that kind of atmosphere in a classroom will ultimately lead to a lot of unhindered curiosity and trust between students and teachers and students and students.

One thought that I had while reading this chapter had to with the effective use of textbooks and implementing alternative strategies in the classroom. If, as a teacher, I decide not to rely so heavily on the textbook, is it acceptable for me to do sort of a one-off teach-aloud to my students explaining to them the flaws and limitations of textbooks? I think that that sort of honesty could be refreshing and encouraging to students who feel that reading textbooks cover to cover is a laborious and only marginally useful task. At the same time, however, will that cause problems for me in the long run? Will I run into opposition from administrators, parents, and fellow teachers if students develop this sort of anti-textbook mentality? I don’t know the answer to any of these questions, but it is certainly something I will be giving a lot of thought to as I move closer to beginning my career as a professional educator. 

Wednesday, March 4, 2015

The Unsinkable RAFT (Strong Chapter 6)

When I think of a raft, I think of a little makeshift boat you float around the ocean in if you’re unlucky enough to get shipwrecked. Pirates and Gilligan’s Island come to mind. Not teaching or designing lessons. But apparently, RAFT (I’m not shouting, it’s an acronym) means something very different to educators. You see, RAFT (or CRAFT, if you’d like to go a little deeper) stands for context, role, audience, format, and topic. It is a widely accepted tool for creating writing assignments that are meaningful, engaging, and well constructed.
Wait a minute. Writing assignments can be engaging? If they are thoughtfully and carefully constructed, absolutely. Creating an engaging and significant writing assignment is accomplished by pulling students into the lesson. No student will ever become interested in the collapse of the Soviet Union if they are forced to write a lengthy research paper about it. Asking them to assume the role of a resident of an Eastern Bloc country writing to a family member about their feelings about the collapse of the Soviet Union, however, will be infinitely more interesting and relevant to them. They will feel involved in the history and be prompted to think about the ramifications of such an important event, rather than just regurgitating facts, dates, and names to you in essay form.
As a future history teacher, one of my biggest fears is getting that question that every educator dreads: so what? Who cares? Why does this matter? This is a sentiment that students will echo across every discipline, but it seems that there are some in which it is more frequent. Math and science, of course, have very tangible, real world applications. Though students may not see it clearly at first, they can usually be made to see it fairly easily. History, on the other hand, is a subject where that significance and relevance is harder to clarify.
How then do you make students understand that what happened fifty, two hundred, or even a thousand years ago is relevant and important to them? You must insert them into the historical narrative. Just as they can be asked to consider the effects of science on modern medicine and technology, (things which almost undoubtedly affect their daily lives) so they can be encouraged to put themselves into the midst of events or times far removed from their own. They can be asked to consider the feelings and motivations of, as well as effects on people living during different historical time periods. Once this is done, we can then go about drawing parallels to the present? For instance, how does the spirit of innovation that burgeoned with the Industrial Revolution still exist in today’s world? How is the present echoed in the past?

Making history relevant to my students is simultaneously my biggest goal and my biggest concern. I understand that it is likely a goal and concern of every educator, but in my personal opinion, that is the only way that history can come alive. I have had more than a few history teachers who made no attempt or a very poor one at making history relevant. I was fortunate enough to have the resilience that encouraged me to remain engaged, but many students don’t. I think that infinitely helpful RAFT format will be an invaluable tool for reaching my students and making them see history not just as a series of disconnected events that happened a long time ago, but as a series of tightly related events that shaped the world as it is today.




I thought this little graphic organizer was kind of neat: 

Wednesday, February 25, 2015

Picking the Right Textbooks and Reading Materials: A Ton of Responsibility (D&Z 3+4)

Textbooks: too heavy, too long, too dense, too expensive, too heavily relied upon. These are only some of the criticisms that you’re bound to hear when discussing textbooks. And you don’t have to be an educator or a student to know that they are consistent and serious issues. What’s worse is that they are all completely valid claims. It seems that at younger and younger ages, students are being forced to purchase expensive and sometimes comically oversized textbooks to ensure that they will learn what they need to in order to pass that all-important end of year standardized test. And therein lies the problem: textbooks DO NOT ensure that students will learn. The only thing that ensures learning takes place in a meaningful and consistent manner is the teacher. How then, do teachers facilitate real learning without that paragon of academic learning, the textbook?  

The first and most important step, but perhaps also the most difficult is to reduce the reliance on textbooks that has become so commonplace in schools across the country. The fact is that textbooks are too long, not comprehensive enough, and written too formally for students to really get anything out of them. We expect students to read five or six textbooks practically cover to cover over the course of a year and are surprised when they don’t retain the information. Sure, textbooks can be useful for drilling dates, definitions, names, places, formulas, and other facts into students’ heads, but this is not what real learning looks like. Real learning entails the recognition, understanding, and analysis of larger and more impactful concepts. When students are able to understand and discuss things that affect everyday life, then real learning has taken place. Textbooks alone cannot teach these things, and so educators must learn to greatly reduce their dependence on them and start to incorporate reading materials from other disciplines, genres, and styles into their teaching.

            
Even though I do not yet have my own classroom, I am confident in saying that my biggest concern as an educator will be encouraging critical and independent thought among my students. I think this is something that I’ve always placed a premium on, so it worries me when teachers (especially history teachers) rely mostly or solely on a textbook to do a majority of the teaching. For the most part, textbooks cannot and will not encourage students to think for themselves. They will present information as hard and indisputable fact that should not be questioned. Granted, for subjects such as math and science which are inherently fact based, this is acceptable, or at least more so than in some other subjects. But even then, there needs to be some room allowed for students to question what they are learning without the fear of reproach or ridicule. Curiosity and healthy skepticism are the foundation for conscious, critically, and independently thinking adults. Students need to know that there are multiple angles from which all things can and should be considered. I think my favorite passage from these two chapters is the following: “Whether it is intentional or not, it is unacceptable for schools in a democracy to teach young people that only one view is sufficient…” (Daniels and Zemelman, 56). This accurately captures the very essence of why I want to become a teacher. And the way that young people are taught that only one view is sufficient is by having them read textbooks page by page and having them memorize and recite facts back to you. This is a wholly unacceptable way of teaching, and something I resolve never to do in my career as an educator.




Wednesday, January 28, 2015

Literacy Profile

It is sometimes hard for me to believe that it has been eight and a half years since I walked into that small gym at the YMCA in Woonsocket, RI for my first fencing class. In the time since that first class, I have become literate in all things fencing. It was not, however, an easy journey, and continues to present me with challenges and opportunities for personal growth even now.
            People inevitably ask how I became interested in fencing and the story is a bit of an unusual one. I was watching TV one day and saw a car commercial that contained clips of two people fencing. This was, I assume, to highlight the car’s agility, speed, grace, etc. What caught my attention, however, was the fencing itself. I expressed interest in pursuing the sport and my parents soon had me signed up for classes at a club based out of the local YMCA.
            Walking into the club that first night was a nerve-wracking experience. Twelve-year-old me was shy and soft-spoken, so meeting new people and trying something new was not exactly in my wheelhouse. Furthermore, I was not nor have I ever been an athletic person. My strengths have always been academic, so my experiences with sports were few and far between. My mind was almost immediately put at ease, though. The people at the club were warm, welcoming, and supportive, which motivated me to keep going back and keep trying. Soon, I was at the club three nights a week.
            Of course, I didn’t get to where I am today merely by showing up. Like anything in life, you need to practice to improve, so I took class once or twice a week. In these classes, I learned the skills, techniques, and thought processes necessary to be a successful fencer. I did drills that helped to improve my footwork and bladework, the necessary components of good fencing. I observed and discussed fencing bouts and actions with my coaches and clubmates in order to better understand the mental aspect of the sport. Taking class, coupled with fencing regularly with my clubmates provided me with hours upon hours of practice, discussion, material for analysis, and lessons.
            Once I had been fencing for about two years and felt comfortable enough to do so, I began attending competitions in the area. This opened up whole new worlds in how I physically, mentally and emotionally approached my fencing. I started beginning to train to keep up with fencers who were older, stronger, faster, and more experienced than myself. I also began to work closely with one of my coaches on strengthening my mental game. I became increasingly well versed in keeping myself calm and composed under pressure. These new approaches to my fencing of course affected my game both at the club and at competitions, and I improved as an overall fencer dramatically.
            I believe that the most important literacy practice I utilize in my fencing is my position as a coach’s assistant at my club. As a coach’s assistant, I am often responsible for leading stretches, footwork, and other drills. I also provide support to fencers while they are in class. This can take the form of encouragement, coaching them while they are fencing a bout, or correcting their hands or feet so they can better execute particular actions in the future. The reason that I think coaching has been such an invaluable part of my fencing experience is that it has allowed me to look at the sport from a completely different angle. It has taught me how to be a leader, how to teach, how to analyze my own fencing, and how to be responsible. Being a fencer and a fencer alone affords you only one viewpoint on the sport. Being a fencer and a coach, however, allows you to see problems with other people’s fencing as well as your own, teaches you how to deal with those problems, and forces you to become positive, analytical, and a good role model.

            To say that fencing has had a positive impact on my life would be an understatement. Fencing has provided me with confidence, self-esteem, and opportunities that I did not previously have and possibly never would. It has made me a more skilled critical thinker, a stronger leader, and a better person than I ever was before. Being a coach is, of course, preparing me for my future as a teacher in obvious ways. But even just participating in the sport without coaching is helping me reach my future goals as a teacher. Fencing has taught me the intellectual strength necessary for educating students in an environment where not everyone is the same and there are constant challenges to teaching the material effectively and efficiently. It has also taught me to be persistent and focused, something that will be invaluable as I write and rewrite lesson plans, determine how to best teach material, and constantly push my students to be the very best that they can be. I can say with confidence that fencing is behind only my friends and family as the most important thing in my life, and something that has provided me with the skills and knowledge necessary to be a successful teacher in the future.